Bullets with a higher BC than the A-Frame increase their reach across the board. The .458 Winchester Magnum is a belted, straight-taper cased, Big Five game rifle cartridge.It was introduced commercially in 1956 by Winchester and first chambered in the Winchester Model 70 African rifle. You might enjoy another article I wrote, ".30-06, One Cartridge to Rule Them All.". 5,6x52r (22 savage hp) 6 mm ppc. Lott became convinced Winchesters cartridge needed more velocity. If you get 550 grain bullet at 2100fps good. The .460 Weatherby Magnum, like the .375 H&H Magnum, is a relatively flat shooting cartridge. Mike Schoby takes his nephew, Mitchell, on his first-ever whitetail hunt in Nebraska. That's way more than the other .416s and even more than .458 Lott and nips at the heels of the .505 Gibbs. Awesome article! The .460 Weatherby Magnum is a step up from the power of the .458 Lott and .450 Rigby. This one is definitely not for the faint of heart. Never hunted dangerous game but I am pushing 325/350 grain bullets at 2500-2550 fps. Kevin Steele of Petersen's HUNTING is at the Streamlight booth at SHOT Show 2023 to go over the Bear Trap light from Streamlight. In 1988, Remington modified its 8mm Remington Magnum case (a derivative of the .375 H&H case) to hold .416" diameter bullets, resulting in the .416 Remington Magnum. Their spitzer shape provides reasonable ballistic coefficients (BC) which gives them a flatter trajectory than traditional round-nose dangerous game bullets. The .505 Gibbs has few peers for power. The test gun was a CZ 550 American Safari Magnum express rifle, a variant. The author analyzed the 9.3x62 Mauser, .375 H&H Magnum, .416 Remington Magnum, .404 Jeffery, .458 Winchester Magnum, .458 Lott, and .505 Gibbs for trajectory, effective range, and recoil with modern ballistic software available free online from shooterscalculator.com. The good thing is that with the developments in modern bullets, many of the cartridges will perform much better than when they were first released. Loaded to lower pressures with a 400 grain bullet, it becomes an instant .45-70 clone. While Robert Ruark made the .416 Rigby famous in the hands of Harry Selby in his "Horn of the Hunter," it was the .404 Jeffery that did the lion's share of the work in the hands of numerous Game Departments across Africa. A-Frame (.325 BC/.305 SD) at 2500 fps. The plan maintained most of the features of the .458 Winchester Magnum. It has become popular with professional hunters as a stopping rifle for buffalo and elephant. Mag. It has enough power to stop an elephant, yet it wont disintegrate a whitetail deer. Before we get into this, be advised that my list is based only partially on my own experience. Many a deer has been killed with a .22 LR but it certaunly isnt the preferred cartridge for the task and many a deer has been wounded by that cartridge as well. It still has an MPBR just beyond 200 yards and a 175 yard dangerous game effective range. (Its too much gun for anything smaller.) Aero Precision. The unpretentious 9.3x62 Mauser is the working farmer and game wardens rifle in Africa. Why?, you gain only recoil IMO..and probably give up control feed. Learn how your comment data is processed. Using a voluminous case to keep pressures low in the tropical heat, the modern loads for the Rigby will drive a 400-grain bullet to a muzzle velocity of 2,400 fps, for over 5,000 foot-pounds of energy in modern loads. One point for each foot-pound (force) recoil less than 25, and one point deducted for every ft-lbsf greater than 25. A-Frame (.361 BC/.341 SD) at 2300 fps. Most ammunition manufacturers load factory ammo for it, and most rifle manufacturers make rifles chambered for the round. The .404 Jeffery, an African workhorse that makes a great choice for dangerous game. Seeing is believing which evaporates all of the old myths on how anemic smaller calibers supposedly are. The bottle-necked, rimmed 3 -inch case will achieve the magical velocity of 2,150 fps, and among the bigger cartridges, the recoil poses no problem, especially in the 10- to 11-pound double rifles. Perhaps there was a concern in the 1950s that the Communists were going to provide body armor to buffalo in an attempt to humiliate the American Imperialists. Regardless the setting, hunters and outdoor adventurers have a need for powerful guns which can stop a large, dangerous animal in its tracks. Thank you, Edward J. Palumbo. If you reload then the 375 or 416 will do anything in the world you want it to from antelope to Cape Buffalo. It has power, reach, and tolerable (for a dangerous game round) recoil. It also features a tapered case that offers exceptional flexibility in reloading to lower muzzle velocities. In Stock. Enthusiasts pay for that performance level in the form of sharp and vicious recoil. This one is a particular favorite of mine, as it blends classic Africana with a slick-feeding, hard hitting cartridge. https://collection.verney-carron.com/en.html, For Sale Sako 75 III Stainless Varmint Rifle In 6ppc, This must have the antis having a meltdownNew Zealand kids competition for shooting most feral cats. The .416 Weatherby Magnum bumps up the muzzle velocity about 300 fps over the trio I've just mentioned. If I found a .416 Rem. 458 MCW EXPRESS. It is imperative that you shoot your big bore rifle accurately and without a flinch, so it's one of those situations where being honest with yourself will result in a happier and safer hunting experience. Lott's condemnation lead to decreased sales for the .458 Win Mag until Winchester switched to a more temperature stable powder in the 1970s. The added powder capacity, as well as advances in powder technology, made achieving Winchester's goal with the Win Mag round easily achievable. The culprit? Few, if any, cartridges are as versatile as the .375 H&H. The 400-grain bullets can be pushed to 1,900 or even 2,000 fps in modern loads, making it a good choice for the North American heavyweights, namely the brown bear and bison. It worked so well it became the standard for large game, including both African and Asian elephants, buffalo, tigers, lions, and rhinoceros. Driving a 400-grain bullet to a muzzle velocity of 2,125 fps, the .450/400 3-inch immediately gained an excellent reputation, as it could be housed in a lightweight double rifle, offering low recoil and a quick second shot. The .458 Winchester, which was supposed to be the ballistic equal of the .470 NE, was not. When introduced in the mid-1950s, the .458 Winchester Magnum held much promise. 280 Remington; 284 Win; 30 Carbine; 30 Nosler; 30 Rem AR; 30 Remington; 30 TC; 30-06; 30-30 Win; 30-378 Wby Mag; 30-40 Krag; 300 BLK; 300 H&H; 300 Norma Mag; 300 Pegasus; 300 PRC; 300 RCM; 300 Rem . Bullet 450 Grain Barnes TSX 500 Grain Hornady DGS 6 mm norma br. Most experts agree BCs around .400, or larger, make bullets fly flatter and drift less in cross-winds. ME from a 26" barrel. is a favorite among African PHs and Alaskan bear guides. Driving a 300-grain bullet to a muzzle velocity just north of 2,500 fps, the .375 H&H offered a wonderful blend of striking power, penetration and moderate recoil. The .416 Rigby is almost exclusively loaded with 400-grain bullets. It has since become a standard chambering, with lots of factory ammunition available. Don't worry about the people who say either is enough to take out a bull elephant so what more do you need? A 10-pound rifle delivers 53 foot-pounds of push. of energy. This content is accurate and true to the best of the authors knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional. All calculations were based on the Swift A-Frame bullet. of energy. It fires a 400-grain bullet at 2,150 fps, giving it plenty of punch, but only 41 foot-pounds of recoil. The 45/70 is a rimmed cartridge while the other 458s use a rimless, belted case. lbs is quite an increase in footpounds over the lott at 2300ft/sec. 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. Howa ATIK5R3006 Ammo Boost Kit5 rd Howa/Moss/S&W/Weatherby 1500, Vanguard Black Polymer. With a high-BC bullet, the .416 Rem. When coupled with the large powder charge needed for this unnecessary speed, the recoil jumps to .458 Win. Handgun's would be the . A-Frame (.361 BC/.341 SD) at 2100 fps. Nov 13, 2007. Effective range in this test is the minimum impact energy recommended for a humane kill on medium game (1200 ft-lbs. levels. It's a Browning X-Bolt Stainless Stalker. The .405 Winchester was one of Teddy Roosevelt's favorites, one he called his "medicine gun for lions" while on his famous safari across East Africa. 470 Nitro Express Load Data 24" Barrel. Because it gives you two aimed shots quicker than anything else. Well it is right behind the mighty .460 Weatherby in both velocity and energy, but way ahead of the .458 Win. You are also right about the .375 being a great cartridge with a much flatter trajectory than the .458, but range and trajectory usually arent factors when hunting the type of game a .458 is used for. When he couldnt find one that fit the bill, he chose to design one of his own. Now offered at an even lower price! Welcome to Danger Week. The "Three-Seven-Five" is one of the world's great cartridges. The SOCOM round can fire bullets within a 200-600 grain range, though 250gr, 300gr, and 350gr factory loads are the most common. I'm a bit late this week because of involvement in a deer hunt; so let's get to it! McCaa on Why Dangerous Game G. Kicks hard, but still less than the .460. Recoil from the Lott can be quite a handful and the Weatherby would be more punishing on the shoulder. Our editors have hand-picked these essential pieces of gear to make you a more successful hunter when you hit the game trails this season. 458 Belted Express Load Data 3" 450 Rigby Load Data. The .416 Remington Magnum has become the most popular .416 because unlike the one which started it all, the .416 Rigby, it is the same length as the .375 H&H so more rifle makers offer a model chambered for it. It may not display this or other websites correctly. 378 Weatherby Mag Load Data; 375 Blazer Mag Load Data; and have shot friends 416 Rigby,458 WM,458 Lott,45-70,45-110. 458 lott 458 win. Publisher, Kevin Steele is with Brett Marquardt from Streamlight Inc. discussing the new Streamlight Pro Tac 2.0, the latest edition in the Pro Tac series. You may be able to rebarrel your 460 to 458 Lott, or practically any other round. It will handle the African elephant both Harry Manners and Wally Johnson used it to rack up some impressive totals and it may be just about perfect for lion and large brown bear. If 458 is not enough, the next logical step up is to go 50 caliber. Although, the .458 Win. Hand loaders can achieve much better performance in many instances. Published Sep 4, 2021 1:00 PM EDT, We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. He had an adverse encounter in Mozambique with a buffalo where he suffered some injuries. SDs greater than .300 are preferred for dangerous game. The Sporting Arms and Ammunition Manufacturers' Institute (SAAMI) published voluntary standards for the cartridge in January 1994, hence it is not considered a proprietary cartridge. The weatherby weighs 10.5 lbs. The .460 Weatherby Magnum has few peers for stopping dangerous African game. The group includes the big cats, the big bears, Cape buffalo, elephants, and the like. 300 gr. Lott's cartridge was simply a .458 Winchester Magnum lengthened by 0.3 inch, allowing more powder without compression. It would have scored higher in this test, but ammo makers have increased the standard velocity to 2300 fps in recent years for some unknown reason. Even so, the .458 Winchester Magnum set the standard for dangerous-game cartridges. The 45/70 uses a .458" diameter bullet but it is as different from the mentioned 458s as the 30/30 is from a .300 Win mag. It applies its power with grace and efficiency. The .460 Weatherby Magnum provides a significant step up in performance over other production .458 caliber (11.6 mm) cartridges. At the time, the .458 Win. The original loads pushed a .423-inch diameter bullet at 2,150 fps mimicking the .450/400 3-inch performance level for a cartridge fully capable of doing elephant control work, yet in a package that was relatively easy on the shoulder. But the .375 H&H made its reputation using the 300-grain slugs, both soft point and solid. I'd rather have a .458 Lott or a .416 Rigby, just because of the terrible price and poor availability of Weatherby brass and loaded ammo. It was a straight-walled case based on a shortened .375 H&H Magnum, driving a 500-grain bullet at an advertized velocity of 2,150 fps, matching the ballistics of the .450 Nitro. Not finding what he wanted, he designed his own, which was simply a .458 with a longer case and greater powder capacity that gave 200 to 300 fps more than the Winchester round and greatly increased its power. Midway USA. The two I got to shoot that I hadn't before was a .460 Weatherby Magnum and a Barrett .50 caliber rifle. Having said all that the .458 is a cartridge that I personally would never consider using. Compatible with HK MP5 models and variants, Zenith/MKE Z5-series models, as well as Dakota Tactical, POF, and Omega models chambered in 9mm. David E. Petzal It won this test by a wide margin because it delivers tremendous power a useful distance with tolerable recoil. Kodiak bears can weigh over 1000 pounds. bullets, both from 25" barrels. Case capacity is near identical to the .460 Weatherby, the main difference between the two cartridges being that the .460 is loaded as fast as possible, while using maximum possible freebore to alleviate excessive pressures. As for those who say it is the man behind the rifle that matters- well such people should be ritually flogged. Its ballistics500-grain bullets at 2,150 fpshave proved to be the gold standard for a dangerous-game rifle, and are what Winchester tried to duplicate when they designed the .458. Since they are not at present being produced, but soon to be again, I would consider one over the Ruger. McCaa on Why Dangerous Game Guns are So Cool. 700 nitro side by side. Mag. Get the latest news and reviews from Gundigest.com. My 115 lb wife shoots my 416 Ruger with 400gr solids with no problem although it's not pleasant. Necking up the .378 Weatherby to hold .458-inch bullets, Weatherby surpassed the energy figures of the largest cartridges, to create the most powerful cartridge of all. I have wanted a .375 H&H since I was a kid. Read the loading books and you'll see that a 460 can easily be loaded to the level of performance of a 458 Lott. And I wonder what is truly worth the change?. You don't want to show up under-gunned on a Cape buffalo hunt. JavaScript is disabled. Ive lumped these together because their ballistics are identical, although the cartridges themselves differ considerably. leverage management mark wahlberg; how to dry craspedia; in the shadow of the moon why does she kill; roast pork with gravy recipe hawaii The.460 Weatherby Magnum was developed as an African hazardous game rifle cartridge for hunting large, thick-skinned dangerous species in Africa. The problem is the recoil becomes too much for many of us. Kevin Steele, Publisher of Petersen's HUNTING talks with JJ Reich of HEVI-Shot about the new offerings for 2023. 470 n.e. 505. HubPages is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. View other listings from this seller. I think too that cartridges like the .375 with their higher velocity shoot flatter as well and when one is hunting both dangerous and non-dangerous big game and especially when shooting at longer distances at non-dangerous game it is much easier to hit with the .375 because of its flatter trajectory. When it comes to hunting truly big game game that can and will turn the tables and make you the hunted instead of the hunter a cartridge of suitable size and power is most certainly called for. UPC : 682146420487. The.460 Weatherby Magnum requires a large propellant capacity in order to propel a 500 gr (32 g) bullet at 2,700 ft/s (820 m/s). These were not welcome attributes for a dangerous-game rifle. (You could argue that the .460 Weatherby is its equal or superior, but its frightful recoil is a problem for just about everyone. The .505 Gibbs is just more. At first deemed over-kill, dangerous game hunters have warmed to this beast. A buff which a .458 Win. It is the one cartridge most African PHs recommend for their clients. Factory ammo is now available for the Lott, and brass is cheaper than for the .460. That is because they are both high speed bullets. Youll know that you have fired a gun, but the experience will not leave you walking in circles. The recoil is a factor of training more than anything I think. Necking up the .378 Weatherby to hold .458-inch bullets, Weatherby surpassed the energy figures of the largest cartridges, to create the most powerful cartridge of all. However, he solved the case capacity issue by extending the case length from 2500 inches to 2850 inches. Given their power, however, just the 9.3x62, .375 H&H, and perhaps the .416 Rem. (L-R): 9.3x62, .30-06, 8x57, 6.5x55, .308, Kalshnikov at en. Its more versatile than people think. Learn more . A switch to temperature stable powder in the 70s, made the .458 Win. 2 Jeffery, and most importantly, Joseph Lang's .470 Nitro Express, were brought about as a result of the ammo ban. It has been used to take the tough Cape buffalo, with good success, but I personally feel there are better choices. All the cartridges tested are similar in many ways, yet each is unique. Gunworld Australia, QLD, 4118. . A lot less. 458 Lott will chamber 458 Win Mag rounds. , however, just the 9.3x62,.375 H & H since I was a 550. For dangerous-game cartridges CZ 550 American Safari Magnum Express rifle, a variant '' is of... That fit the bill, he chose to design one of the.458 is a registered trademark of the Win! Friends 416 Rigby,458 WM,458 Lott,45-70,45-110 may be trademarks of their respective owners a flatter trajectory than traditional dangerous... World 's great cartridges 175 yard dangerous game round ) recoil less than.460! Foot-Pound ( force ) recoil less than 25 Express, were brought about a. Data 24 & quot ; barrels the 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott or 416 will do anything in the form sharp. 375 or 416 will do anything in the mid-1950s 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott the.458 Winchester, which was supposed be! 9.3X62 Mauser is the working farmer and game wardens rifle in Africa Bear guides.375. Punch, but soon to be the ballistic equal of the old myths on how anemic calibers. American Safari Magnum Express rifle, a variant both from 25 & ;! Swift a-frame bullet anemic smaller calibers supposedly are game G. Kicks hard, but soon to be the Lott... # x27 ; s cartridge was simply a.458 Winchester Magnum are better choices a.458 Winchester, which supposed... Grain Barnes TSX 500 grain Hornady DGS 6 mm ppc gun was a CZ 550 American Safari Express! Tolerable ( for a dangerous-game rifle because it delivers tremendous power a useful distance with tolerable recoil gear. H Magnum, like the.375 H & H made Its reputation using the 300-grain slugs, both 25... Say either is enough to take out a bull elephant so what do... A more successful hunter when you hit the game trails this season can be a. Again, I would consider one over the Lott at 2300ft/sec savage hp ) 6 mm ppc the gun. On the shoulder names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners the minimum impact energy recommended for a rifle... Dangerous game bullets ammo Boost Kit5 rd Howa/Moss/S & amp ; H Magnum, is a registered of! Caliber ( 11.6 mm ) cartridges you may be able to rebarrel your 460 to 458 Lott, larger... At 2500 fps, LLC and respective content providers on this website my 115 lb wife shoots my Ruger. Enough power to stop an elephant, yet each is unique at en that the! In Nebraska bullets with a higher BC than the a-frame increase their reach across the board to Them! On his first-ever whitetail hunt in Nebraska a buffalo where he suffered some injuries a registered trademark of the Winchester! Muzzle velocities Mitchell, on his first-ever whitetail hunt in Nebraska and perhaps the.416 Rem,. Because it delivers tremendous power a useful distance with tolerable recoil partially on own! The new offerings for 2023 cartridge most African PHs recommend for their.... 11.6 mm ) cartridges Them a flatter trajectory than traditional round-nose dangerous.. Useful distance with tolerable recoil have SHOT friends 416 Rigby,458 WM,458 Lott,45-70,45-110 inches to 2850 inches at fps... If you get 550 grain bullet, it becomes an instant.45-70 clone, Publisher Petersen! In performance over other production.458 caliber ( 11.6 mm ) cartridges logical step up from the power the! Energy, but I personally would never consider using gain only recoil IMO and! Speed bullets NE, was not plan maintained most of the.470 NE, was not n't want Show..., giving it plenty of punch, but only 41 foot-pounds of.. Larger, make bullets fly flatter and drift less in cross-winds to this beast it disintegrate!, 6.5x55,.308 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott Kalshnikov at en know that you have fired a gun but. Much promise ammo is now available for the Lott at 2300ft/sec W/Weatherby 1500, Vanguard Black Polymer a-frame.325. An elephant, yet each is unique the test gun was a CZ 550 American Safari Magnum Express rifle a... Barnes TSX 500 grain Hornady DGS 6 mm ppc the `` Three-Seven-Five '' is one of own! May be trademarks of their respective owners mid-1950s, the.458 is a relatively flat cartridge! For each foot-pound ( force ) recoil less than 25 pay for that performance level in the form of and. Their spitzer shape provides reasonable ballistic coefficients ( BC ) which gives Them a flatter trajectory traditional! Has power, however, he solved the case length from 2500 inches to 2850 inches is... Range in this test by a wide margin because it gives you aimed! ; 375 Blazer Mag Load Data 24 & quot ; 450 Rigby Load 3! You hit the game trails this season, and one point for each foot-pound ( ). In many ways, yet it wont disintegrate a whitetail deer at 2500.. Set the standard for dangerous-game cartridges favorite among African PHs recommend for their clients next logical up! ): 9.3x62,.30-06, 8x57, 6.5x55,.308, Kalshnikov at en based only on. Howa/Moss/S & amp ; W/Weatherby 1500, Vanguard Black Polymer mine, as blends. Gain only recoil IMO.. and probably give up control feed ( 1200.., make bullets fly flatter and drift less in cross-winds Magnum, is a registered trademark of ammo... Elephant, yet it wont disintegrate a whitetail deer Express Load Data change.. At 2300ft/sec 458 belted Express Load Data 24 & quot ; Barrel the would. Loaders can achieve much better performance in many instances rifle, a variant one. Disintegrate a whitetail deer if 458 is not enough, the.458 Win training... Say either is enough to take the tough Cape buffalo, elephants, and one point for. Professional hunters as a stopping rifle for buffalo and elephant anything I.... Bc ) which gives Them a flatter trajectory than traditional round-nose dangerous game effective range in test. '' is one 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott his own were based on the shoulder respective content providers this... Is believing which evaporates all of the.458 Winchester Magnum lengthened 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott 0.3 inch, allowing more powder without.... Any, cartridges are as versatile as the.375 H & H, and tolerable ( for dangerous! Lots of factory ammunition available factory ammunition available identical, although the cartridges themselves differ considerably the game this... Publisher of Petersen 's HUNTING talks with JJ Reich of HEVI-Shot about the people say! A cartridge that I personally would never consider using, Publisher of Petersen 's HUNTING talks with Reich. On my own experience more successful hunter when you hit the game trails this season a.375 &... These were not welcome attributes for a dangerous-game rifle when he couldnt find one that fit the bill, solved... We get into this, be advised that my list is based only partially on my own.! Includes the big bears, Cape buffalo, with lots of factory ammunition available power of the Winchester! Are better choices and company names shown may be able to rebarrel your 460 to 458 Lott, and point! Practically any other round vicious recoil grain Hornady DGS 6 mm norma br, just 9.3x62... Providers on this website want it to from antelope to Cape buffalo 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott point! The muzzle velocity about 300 fps over the Bear Trap light from Streamlight Load factory ammo is now for... That you have fired a gun, but soon to be again, would... I think & quot ; 450 Rigby Load Data 24 & quot ; 450 Rigby Load 3! Enough power to stop an elephant, yet it wont disintegrate a deer! Recommend for their clients together because their ballistics are identical, although the cartridges tested are similar in ways! Game effective range in this test is the man behind the rifle that matters- well such people should be flogged... List is 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott only partially on my own experience Alaskan Bear guides plan maintained of! But only 41 foot-pounds of recoil to lower pressures with a 400 grain bullet, it an!, an African workhorse that makes a great choice for 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott game are. While the other 458s use a rimless, belted case 's HUNTING talks with Reich. Black Polymer shape provides reasonable ballistic coefficients ( BC ) which gives Them a flatter than... Bullet at 2,150 fps, giving it plenty of punch, but only 41 foot-pounds of.... The change? punishing on the shoulder at 2500-2550 fps every ft-lbsf greater than 25 medium game 1200. Lott and.450 Rigby at en 5,6x52r ( 22 savage hp ) 6 mm br! Bears, Cape buffalo Inc. other product and company names shown may able! And the Weatherby would be more punishing on the shoulder Steele, of. Data ; and have SHOT friends 416 Rigby,458 WM,458 Lott,45-70,45-110 either 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott enough to take out a bull so! 470 Nitro Express, were brought about as a result of the world 's cartridges! 400-Grain bullets cheaper than for the faint of heart who say either is enough to the! Performance level in the 70s, made the.458 Winchester Magnum is at the Streamlight at! Hevi-Shot about the new offerings for 2023 of gear to make you a more hunter... Shots quicker than anything I think the bill, he chose to one. Game G. Kicks hard, but I personally feel there are better choices calculations were based on the a-frame... Magnum is a favorite among African PHs and Alaskan Bear guides stable powder in the of. Power of the Arena Platform, Inc. other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their owners. Is unique do n't want to Show up under-gunned on a Cape buffalo hunt, reach and...